Defense: Crystal Mangum 'nicked' boyfriend's colon with kni - WHLT 22 Connecting the Pine Belt

Defense: Crystal Mangum 'nicked' boyfriend's colon with knife

Posted: Updated:
The court also heard 911 calls made the night of the stabbing by Wilson and Mangum. At one point, Mangum began crying while listening to the recordings. The court also heard 911 calls made the night of the stabbing by Wilson and Mangum. At one point, Mangum began crying while listening to the recordings.
DURHAM, N.C. -

After two full days of jury selection, Crystal Mangum's murder trial began in Durham with opening statements and witness testimony Thursday afternoon.

Mangum, who falsely accused Duke lacrosse players of rape in 2006, is charged with the murder of her boyfriend, Reginald Daye.

Mangum is accused of stabbing Daye during a domestic dispute April 3, 2011, at his apartment in Durham. She has claimed she stabbed her boyfriend in self-defense. Mangum is also charged with larceny.

She has pleaded not guilty to all charges.

Assistant District Attorney Charlene Coggins-Franks outlined for the jury what they will hear during the coming days.

She said Mangum and Daye went to a party on the evening of April 3 and at some point started to argue.

Franks said Mangum used a knife to stab Daye, went out of the house and to a cousin's apartment, where she told someone what happened.

Franks said it was only after talking with other people that Mangum called 911 and hung up before giving all of the information she needed to give.

Ten days after the stabbing, Daye died, Franks said.

Defense attorney Daniel Meier said he and Mangum do not disagree with everything the state says.

He confirmed Mangum and Daye got into an argument.

Meier said throughout the trial, the jury will hear Daye's perspective through witnesses who talked with him.

Daye admitted to holding Mangum down on the bed until she calmed down and stopped "disrespecting" him, Meier said.

At one point during the argument, Mangum locked herself in the bathroom, Meier told the jury.

Daye thought she was calling police and kicked the door down, ripping it off the frame, and went into the bathroom, dragging Mangum into the bedroom by her hair, Meier said.

At that point, Mangum stabbed Daye a single time in his side, Meier said.

Daye never hit Mangum, but admitted to holding her down and dragging her by her hair, Meier said, adding that Mangum tried to leave three times, but Daye wouldn't let her go.

Daye was taken to Duke University Medical Center, and where it was discovered his colon was "nicked" by the knife, Meier said.

He had surgery and was expected to fully recover, Meier said.

On April 6, Daye had a lack of oxygen to his brain, and went brain dead. He was then taken off of life-support, Meier said.

The prosecution began calling witnesses to the stand Thursday.

Daye's cousin, Hasan Wilson, testified that he did not see Mangum and Daye arguing the night of the stabbing.

Carlos Wilson, Daye's nephew, then testified that Daye showed up at his door "somewhat in a panic state" bleeding after the stabbing. Wilson was the first to call 911.

"He was trying to stay calm, but he was in a lot of pain," Wilson said.

He said he saw the apartment where the stabbing happened, seeing a mess and the knife.

"I couldn't get the image of how the apartment looked out of my head," Wilson said.

Wilson testified he did not see Mangum at the apartment at that time.

He also said that it "didn't take much to push the door in" on the bathroom, saying it was a "cheap fabrication."

Wilson said Daye did not have a history of abusing girlfriends, adding he was usually the one abused.

"Reggie was more of a lover than a fighter," he said.

"I used to joke with him a lot about women beating him up," Wilson said.

The court also heard 911 calls made the night of the stabbing by Wilson and Mangum. At one point, Mangum began crying while listening to the recordings.

Durham Police Officer Bradley Frey, who testified he was the second or third officer on the scene, said he saw two or three knives in the apartment. One of them was stabbed into a couch. Officer Frey also said he saw three bottles of beer and a trail of blood droplets in the apartment and then found Daye.

Officer Frey said that Daye told him he and Mangum were arguing about money.

Officer C.N. Walker said when officers found Mangum, she was lying face down on the floor of her aunt's house.

"It kind of appeared she was intoxicated," he said.

He asked her at least twice to stand up, before having to help her off the floor.

When Walker took Mangum to the police department, he said she "kept trying to wiggle" out of her handcuffs, and successfully got the handcuffs off of one hand.

The judge dismissed the jury at 3:30 p.m. Thursday.

The trial in Durham County Superior Court is expected to take about five to seven days. Judge Paul Ridgeway of Wake County told potential jurors the trial could potentially continue into the week of Thanksgiving or after.

RELATED STORIES

  • Durham CountyMore>>

  • Duke University to hold Michael Brown forum Monday night

    Duke University to hold Michael Brown forum Monday night

    Monday, September 1 2014 12:32 PM EDT2014-09-01 16:32:26 GMT
    Lesley McSpadden, right, the mother of 18-year-old Michael Brown, watches as Brown's father, Michael Brown Sr., holds up a family pictureduring a news conference Aug. 11, 2014, in Ferguson, Mo. (AP Photo/Jeff Roberson)Lesley McSpadden, right, the mother of 18-year-old Michael Brown, watches as Brown's father, Michael Brown Sr., holds up a family pictureduring a news conference Aug. 11, 2014, in Ferguson, Mo. (AP Photo/Jeff Roberson)
    The issues surrounding the deadly police shooting in Ferguson, Mo. will be discussed in the Triangle Monday night when Duke University will hold a town hall forum.
    The issues surrounding the deadly police shooting in Ferguson, Mo. will be discussed in the Triangle Monday night when Duke University will hold a town hall forum.
  • Granville Co. farmer donates 'ugly' corn to local charities

    Granville Co. farmer donates 'ugly' corn to local charities

    Saturday, August 30 2014 5:48 PM EDT2014-08-30 21:48:11 GMT
    Nearly $3,000 worth of corn was donated to the Produce Box by farmer Gary Fuller, of Granville County.Nearly $3,000 worth of corn was donated to the Produce Box by farmer Gary Fuller, of Granville County.
    Rather than throw away thousands of ears of "ugly but good" corn, foiled after very wet summer, a local farmer chose to donate them to the needy.
    Rather than throw away thousands of ears of "ugly but good" corn, foiled after very wet summer, a local farmer chose to donate them to the needy.
  • Former Marine closes in on goal to keep coffee shop open

    Former Marine closes in on goal to keep coffee shop open

    Saturday, August 30 2014 1:50 AM EDT2014-08-30 05:50:17 GMT
    Matt Victoriano's military background influenced every aspect of his Durham coffee house and bar, Intrepid Life.Matt Victoriano's military background influenced every aspect of his Durham coffee house and bar, Intrepid Life.
    A business owner and former Marine says he may be able to keep his Durham coffee shop open after receiving an outpouring of support from the community.
    A business owner and former Marine says he may be able to keep his Durham coffee shop open after receiving an outpouring of support from the community.
  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Col. Holden, first black to lead NC Patrol, dies

    Col. Holden, first black to lead NC Patrol, dies

    Friday, August 22 2014 6:07 PM EDT2014-08-22 22:07:34 GMT
    Col. Richard Holden of Cary, the first African-American to lead the North Carolina Highway Patrol, died Thursday.
    Col. Richard Holden of Cary, the first African-American to lead the North Carolina Highway Patrol, died Thursday.
  • 16-year-old girl stabs another 65 times after nude photos posted on Facebook

    16-year-old girl stabs another 65 times after nude photos posted on Facebook

    Wednesday, April 2 2014 3:29 PM EDT2014-04-02 19:29:36 GMT
    A 16-year-old girl is accused of fatally stabbing her teen ‘best friend' in an attack spurred by nude photos of the pair together posted on social media, according to several media sources.  Anel Baez,
    A 16-year-old girl is accused of fatally stabbing her teen ‘best friend' in an attack spurred by nude photos of the pair together posted on social media, according to several media sources.  Anel Baez,
  • Clemson student suddenly dies from infection

    Clemson student suddenly dies from infection

    Wednesday, August 27 2014 8:38 AM EDT2014-08-27 12:38:27 GMT
    Virginia GilliamVirginia Gilliam
    A Mount Pleasant family is grieving the loss of their 18-year-old daughter and sister after she dies suddenly while away at school in the up state. Clemson freshman Virginia Gilliam died on August 24 after what started out as a urinary tract infection."Anybody that knew Virginia, knew she saw the world through a child's eyes. Again, I knew that, my family knew that and I'm not a big social media guy but since then I've just been seeing all this out pouring," Herb Gilliam. Social Media he says...
    A Mount Pleasant family is grieving the loss of their 18-year-old daughter and sister after she dies suddenly while away at school in the up state. Clemson freshman Virginia Gilliam died on August 24 after what started out as a urinary tract infection."Anybody that knew Virginia, knew she saw the world through a child's eyes. Again, I knew that, my family knew that and I'm not a big social media guy but since then I've just been seeing all this out pouring," Herb Gilliam. Social Media he says...
Powered by WorldNow

5912 Hwy. 49, Ste. A
Hattiesburg, MS 39401

Telephone: 601.545.2077
Fax: 601.545.3589
Email: newsroom@whlt.com

Can't find something?
Powered by WorldNow
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 Media General Communications Holdings, LLC. A Media General Company.